“This Exceeds All Legal, Ethical, Moral and Humanitarian Norms” When the Head of the ICRC Issues a Warning to the World.

In an interview with the Dutch newspaper NRC, President of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), delivered a stark assessment of the war in Gaza:

“What we have seen in Gaza exceeds all legal, ethical, moral and humanitarian norms.”

For an institution known for restraint, neutrality, and careful language, this was extraordinary.

But it was not an isolated remark.

Over the past year, Spoljaric has issued a series of deeply troubling statements about Gaza — warnings that go beyond political critique and into the realm of systemic humanitarian collapse.

“Humanity Is Failing in Gaza”

In multiple interviews and public remarks, Spoljaric has framed the crisis not merely as a military conflict, but as a moral test for the international system:

“Humanity is failing in Gaza.”

This is not diplomatic phrasing. It is an indictment of collective inaction.

When the guardian of the Geneva Conventions says humanity itself is failing, it means the norms meant to protect civilians are being overwhelmed by the conduct of war.

“There Was Not a Minute Without Gunfire”

After visiting Gaza, she described the environment in hauntingly personal terms:

“There was not a minute when you didn’t hear gunfire.”

On returning months later, she reportedly found entire neighborhoods gone — erased.

The laws of war were designed precisely for dense civilian environments like Gaza.
When destruction reaches the point where areas become unrecognizable, the principle of proportionality is no longer an abstract legal doctrine — it becomes a measurable human tragedy.

“Worse Than Hell on Earth”

In a widely cited broadcast interview, Spoljaric described Gaza as:

“Worse than hell on Earth.”

She emphasized that civilians are being stripped not only of safety, but of dignity — forced into displacement, deprivation, and constant fear.

The ICRC does not exaggerate. It negotiates access. It works quietly.
For its President to use such language signals extraordinary distress.

On Self-Defence and Legal Limits

When asked whether Israel’s right to self-defence justifies the scale of the campaign, Spoljaric was unequivocal:

“That is no excuse for breaking the law.”

International humanitarian law does not disappear because a state invokes self-defence.
The right to defend oneself exists within the boundaries of distinction, proportionality, and civilian protection.

Remove those boundaries, and war becomes unrestrained force.

“We Cannot Accept Warfare That Leads to This Situation”

Another powerful statement from Spoljaric:

“We cannot accept warfare that leads to this situation.”

This is perhaps the most consequential warning.

If the international community normalizes this level of devastation — if it adjusts its moral baseline downward — then Gaza becomes precedent.

And precedents travel.

On the Collapse of Legal Norms

Spoljaric has also warned that Gaza may represent one of the clearest modern examples of the erosion of international humanitarian law.

Her concern is not only about one war.
It is about what happens next.

If civilian infrastructure can be reduced to rubble at this scale…
If humanitarian workers can be killed…
If aid can be obstructed…
And if this becomes politically manageable —

Then the Geneva Conventions lose their deterrent force.

The Protection of Medical and Humanitarian Workers

The ICRC has lost colleagues in Gaza. Ambulances have been struck. Aid workers have died.

Under international law, medical personnel and humanitarian workers are explicitly protected.

Spoljaric expressed devastation at these deaths and emphasized that such incidents “should never happen.”

If even the Red Cross emblem no longer guarantees safety, then the protective architecture of war is fracturing.

Beyond Gaza: A Global Warning

Spoljaric’s statements are not political endorsements.
They are institutional alarms.

Her message is clear:

The scale of suffering in Gaza is unprecedented in contemporary conflict.
Legal limits on warfare are being stretched beyond recognition.
The erosion of humanitarian norms in one place threatens their survival everywhere.

This is why her words matter.

Because when the President of the International Committee of the Red Cross — an organization born out of the carnage of 19th-century battlefields and formalized after the catastrophes of the 20th century — says norms are being exceeded, it means the foundations of post-World War II humanitarian order are under strain.

A Defining Question for Our Time

History will not ask who won tactical ground.

It will ask whether the rules meant to protect civilians survived.

Spoljaric’s warning forces a stark question:

Are the laws of war universal — or conditional?

Because if they are conditional, then no civilian anywhere is truly protected.

And if they are universal, then their violation demands more than silence.

It demands accountability.

Comments

Never Attack a Revolution—Unless It’s Gaza

By Malik Mukhtar There is a peculiar confidence that comes with being wrong for decades and still being invited back to explain the world. Yossi Alpher—former Mossad official, veteran intelligence analyst, and institutional voice of Israeli “realism”—offers us precisely that confidence in his January 12, 2026 reflections on Iran. His message, distilled, is simple: things are complicated, revolutions are unpredictable, and humility is required . This is sound advice. It just arrives from the wrong mouth, at the wrong time, over the wrong bodies. Because while Alpher warns us—correctly—not to “attack a revolution, ” Israel has spent the last two years doing something far more obscene : attacking a trapped civilian population with no revolution , no army , no air force, no escape —and calling it self-defense . Intelligence: A Sacred Failure, Repeated Faithfully Alpher recalls, with admirable candor, the catastrophic ignorance of Western and Israeli intelligence during...

Gaza Beyond the Alibi of Hamas: Genocide as Method, Silence as Accomplice.( From Chris Hedges report )

We are the most informed generation in human history—and perhaps the least disturbed by what we know. From the first missiles that struck Gaza’s residential blocks to the slow starvation that followed, everything was visible. Every destroyed home. Every burned hospital. Every child pulled from rubble. And yet, the global emotional temperature barely rose. In an age of total visibility, feeling itself has become scarce. Watching has replaced witnessing. Knowing has replaced responsibility. This moral numbness is not accidental. It is cultivated . And at the center of this cultivation stands a single word, endlessly repeated, ritually invoked, and strategically deployed: Hamas . Hamas has functioned not as an explanation, but as an alibi. The Choice Was Announcedk From Day One From the earliest days of Israel’s assault, the policy was articulated with chilling clarity: Gaza’s population would be given two options— stay and starve, or leave . This was not the language of counte...

When the Warning Comes from the General Moshe Ya’alon, Jewish Supremacy, and the Echo Nobody Wanted to Hear

History has a cruel sense of irony. Sometimes the most devastating indictments do not come from the oppressed, the bombed, the buried, or the silenced—but from the very architects of power who once swore they were different. This week, that indictment came from Moshe Ya’alon : former Israeli Defense Minister, former IDF Chief of Staff, lifelong pillar of Israel’s security establishment. Not a dissident poet. Not a radical academic. Not a Palestinian survivor. A general. And what he said shattered the last polite illusion. “ The ideology of Jewish supremacy that has become dominant in the Israeli government is reminiscent of Nazi race theory.” Pause there. Sit with it. This was not shouted at a protest . It was not scribbled on a placard. It was written calmly, deliberately, after attending a Holocaust Remembrance ceremony —then reading reports of Jewish settlers attacking Palestinians , blocking ambulances , fracturing skulls , burning homes. Never Again, apparently, now ...

Ras ‘Ein al-‘Auja: How Ethnic Cleansing Happens Without a Declaration

Ethnic cleansing rarely announces itself with sirens or official decrees. More often, it arrives quietly—through sleepless nights, smashed water tanks, stolen sheep, armed men grazing livestock on stolen land, and the slow realization that survival itself has become impossible. On 8 January 2026 , Israel completed what it had been methodically engineering for months: the forcible transfer of 26 Palestinian families from the shepherding community of Ras ‘Ein al-‘Auja in the southern Jordan Valley. That is 124 people , including 59 children , pushed from homes their families had lived in for decades—not by a single evacuation order, but by sustained terror. This is not a humanitarian crisis caused by “clashes.” It is not a byproduct of war. It is a deliberate policy outcome . Violence as Policy, Militias as Instruments Ras ‘Ein al-‘Auja lies about ten kilometers north of Jericho. It is the last remaining shepherding community in the southern Jordan Valley , and the largest sti...

“Not Auschwitz — Yet Still Genocide”: When Israeli Holocaust Historians Break the Silence on Gaza

There are moments in history when the most unsettling truths do not come from one’s enemies, but from within. From those who know the past most intimately. From those whose moral authority is built not on ideology, but on memory. In December 2025, two of Israel’s most respected Holocaust and genocide scholars— Prof. Daniel Blatman and Prof. Amos Goldberg of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem—published a deeply unsettling opinion article in Haaretz . What they argued was not casual, rhetorical, or activist hyperbole. It was a grave historical judgment. Their conclusion was stark: What is happening in Gaza is not Auschwitz. But it belongs to the same family of crimes: genocide. Why This Voice Matters Blatman and Goldberg are not marginal figures. They are historians whose professional lives have been devoted to studying Nazi crimes, genocide mechanisms, memory, and moral responsibility . Their scholarship is rooted in the very catastrophe that shaped modern Jewish iden...

Ainnbeen

Search This Blog