Accepting Hamas’ Survival is Only Path Forward for Gaza. Gideon Levy. Key Points

Detailed overview of Gideon Levy's latest article on Gaza and Palestine.

---

Article Title: "Accepting Hamas’ Survival is Only Path Forward for Gaza"

Published: March 14, 2025, in Haaretz (republished in The Palestine Chronicle) .

---

Key Arguments & Overview

1. Hamas Cannot Be Eliminated Militarily

- Levy argues that despite 17 months of brutal war, Israel has failed to destroy Hamas.

- Casualties & Destruction: Over tens of thousands of Gazans killed, yet Hamas remains politically entrenched.

- Quote:

> "After the deaths of hundreds of Israeli soldiers and tens of thousands of Gazans, Hamas remains. After destruction on the scale of Dresden, Hamas remains." .

2. Political Reality: Hamas is Gaza’s Only Governing Force

- Levy dismisses proposals to replace Hamas with the Palestinian Authority (PA) or an international administration as unrealistic.

- Key Point:

> "The king of Gaza will be from Hamas, or anointed with its consent.".

- Hamas, though militarily weakened, has gained political strength by recentering the Palestinian cause globally.

3. Critique of Israel’s Failed Strategy

- Israel’s reliance on "barbaric force" has only deepened Hamas’ legitimacy.

- Historical Failure: Israel’s 2005 Gaza disengagement lacked a long-term political vision, leading to today’s crisis.

4. Call for Direct Negotiations with Hamas

- Levy urges Israel and the U.S. to accept Hamas as a political actor and engage in talks.

- Controversial Stance:

> "We need to talk to the organization. Even, or in fact especially, after October 7."

5. Rejection of Alternative "Day After" Plans

- Levy critiques proposals like Trump’s "Riviera Plan" (mass displacement of Gazans) as fantastical and immoral.

- Reality Check:

> "There is no day after Hamas and presumably there won’t be one anytime soon.".

---

Broader Implications

- Military Futility: Prolonged war only strengthens Hamas’ ideological appeal.

- Political Stalemate: Without Hamas’ inclusion, no governance model for Gaza is viable.

- International Law: Levy condemns Israel’s starvation tactics and collective punishment as violations .

---

Related Context from Other Recent Levy Interviews

1. On Ceasefire Violations (March 2025):

- Israel halted Phase 2 of the ceasefire, blocking aid and hostage releases .

2. On the "Two-State Solution":

- Levy declares it dead, citing 700,000+ settlers making partition impossible .

3. On Media Bias:

- Israeli media erases Palestinian suffering, focusing only on soldiers and hostages .

---

Conclusion

Levy’s article is a scathing indictment of Israel’s Gaza policy, asserting that military solutions have failed and diplomatic engagement with Hamas is unavoidable His stance challenges mainstream Israeli and Western narratives, calling for a radical shift in strategy.

For the full article, see: [The Palestine Chronicle](https://www.palestinechronicle.com/accepting-hamas-survival-is-only-path-forward-for-gaza-gideon-levy/) .

Comments

Dr. Randa Abdel Fattah. De-Invited by Association: When Grief Becomes a Pretext and Palestinian Identity a Liability

How Dr. Randa Abdel-Fattah Was Silenced in the Name of “Sensitivity” In a remarkable feat of moral gymnastics, Australia’s literary establishment has once again demonstrated how grief can be weaponised, principles suspended, and Palestinian identity rendered dangerously “inappropriate ” —all in the name of cultural sensitivity. Dr. Randa Abdel-Fattah , a respected author, academic, and public intellectual, was quietly de-invited from Adelaide Writers’ Week following the Bondi Junction massacre. Not because she had any connection—real, implied, or imagined—to the atrocity. Not because she endorsed violence. Not because she violated any law or ethical standard. But because, apparently, the mere presence of a Palestinian Muslim woman who speaks about justice is now considered culturally unsafe during national mourning . One wonders: unsafe for whom? The Logic of the Absurd Festival organisers were careful—almost impressively so—to state that Dr. Abdel-Fattah had nothing to do wi...

Ana Kasparian: The Voice That Won’t Be Silent — A Call for Truth in an Age of Power

Ana Kasparian is one of the most recognized and outspoken voices in contemporary political media. As a co-host of The Young Turks — a trailblazing online news and commentary program — she has spent nearly two decades dissecting U.S. politics, media, power, and foreign policy with unapologetic clarity and fierce conviction. She is not just a commentator — she is a truth-seeker who challenges power at every turn , refusing to soften her words for comfort. Schooled in journalism and political science, Ana’s commentary continues to mobilize millions, especially younger generations who feel unheard in mainstream discourse. A Voice Against the Status Quo Ana’s rhetoric can be bold, controversial, and deeply passionate — because she refuses to accept narratives that obscure the underlying truth about power and influence. On American democracy and foreign policy, she strikes at the heart of what many hesitate to articulate: “ We don’t actually live in a true democracy here in t...

Gaza and the Collapse of World Order: When the Guardian of Human Rights Sounds the Alarm

There are moments when the language of diplomacy fails, when caution becomes complicity, and when silence becomes an accomplice to destruction. On January 9, 2026, Agnès Callamard—Secretary General of Amnesty International—crossed that threshold. Her words were unambiguous, unprecedented, and devastating: The United States is destroying world order. Israel has been doing so for the last two years. Germany, through complicity and repression, is helping govern its demise. This was not activist rhetoric. It was a diagnosis from the very institution tasked with guarding the moral and legal architecture of the modern world. The Collapse of the Post-War Moral Architecture The international order that emerged after World War II was built on a promise: never again . Never again genocide. Never again collective punishment. Never again impunity for powerful states. That promise was codified in international law, human rights conventions, and multilateral institutions. But Gaza has...

Rebranding Genocide: When Killing Learns New Words

There are moments in history when crimes do not end — they simply learn new language. Gaza is living inside such a moment. The bombs have not stopped falling. The children have not stopped dying. The displaced have not stopped freezing in tents pitched atop rubble that was once their homes. What has changed is the vocabulary . And in the modern age, vocabulary is power . If you can rename atrocity, you can anesthetize conscience. First, it was called self-defense — a phrase emptied of meaning by its repetition. Then it became a war , despite the grotesque imbalance: one side armed with one of the most advanced militaries on earth, backed by the world’s most powerful empire ; the other a besieged civilian population without an army, navy, air force, tanks, or safe shelter. Now it is branded a ceasefire — a word invoked not to stop violence, but to conceal it. This is not peace. It is genocide with a quieter soundtrack. The Illusion of Restraint A slowed rate of killing is not m...

Citizens on Paper, Expendable in Practice Arab Israelis, October 7, and the Failure of International Law Inside the “Only Democracy”

Israel tells the world it is the only democracy in the Middle East . Democracies, we are reminded, protect all citizens equally—especially minorities—especially in times of crisis. Now look at Palestinian citizens of Israel , roughly 20% of the population , in the months following October 7 . Then ask: what exactly does citizenship mean when the state will not protect your life? The Forgotten Fifth of the Population Arab citizens of Israel vote. They hold passports. They pay taxes. They are citizens in the narrow, bureaucratic sense. But international law does not define citizenship by paperwork. It defines it by: Equal protection Non-discrimination The right to life Equal access to justice On those measures, Israel is not merely failing—it is structurally violating its obligations . A Murder Epidemic the State Chooses Not to Stop Long before October 7, Arab towns inside Israel were drowning in violence: Illegal weapons proliferated Organized crime flourished ...

Ainnbeen

Search This Blog