Skip to main content

" Netanyahu's Judicial Coup: Government Passes Bill for Political Takeover of Judicial Appointments" Haaretz. Key Points.

 


The bill is a key part of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's controversial judicial overhaul plan, which has sparked massive protests and deep political divisions in Israel. Here’s a detailed overview of its provisions, implications, and context:


Key Provisions of the Bill

The legislation alters the composition and functioning of the Judicial Appointments Committee, the body responsible for selecting judges in Israel, including Supreme Court justices.  


1. Politicization of Judicial Appointments:  

   - Previously, the nine-member committee included a mix of politicians, judges, and legal professionals, requiring broad consensus for appointments.  

   - The new law changes the balance, giving the governing coalition a de facto majority (7 out of 13 members, after a future expansion) in selecting judges.  

   - The committee will now include:  

     - 3 government ministers (up from 2).  

     - 3 coalition-backed Knesset members (instead of 2, with one traditionally from the opposition).  

     - The Supreme Court president and two other justices (reduced influence).  

     - 2 representatives from the Israel Bar Association (whose role may be weakened in future reforms).  


2. Elimination of Checks and Balances:  

   - The previous system required at least one opposition MK and cooperation between branches of government.  

   - Now, the coalition can push through judicial appointments without opposition or judicial input.  


3. Future Implications for the Supreme Court:  

   - The government could stack the courts with ideologically aligned judges, including the Supreme Court, which has often acted as a check on government power.  

   - Critics warn this could lead to erosion of judicial independence and enable authoritarian policies.  


Why It’s Controversial  

- Power Grab: Opponents argue it undermines democracy by letting politicians control judicial appointments, removing a key check on government power.  

- Part of a Larger Overhaul: This is just one piece of Netanyahu’s broader plan, which includes weakening the Supreme Court’s power to strike down laws (override clause) and reducing judicial review.  

- Protests & Opposition: The reform has triggered months of mass protests, with military reservists, business leaders, and legal experts warning of democratic backsliding.  

- International Concerns: The U.S. and EU have expressed worries about Israel’s democratic stability.  


Netanyahu’s Justification 

- Supporters argue the reforms "restore democracy" by reducing what they see as an overly activist Supreme Court.  

- They claim judges have too much power and are unelected, while the elected government should have more influence.  


What’s Next? 

- The opposition may challenge the law in the Supreme Court, leading to a constitutional crisis if the Court strikes it down and the government refuses to comply.  

- Further reforms are expected, including laws to limit judicial review and weaken the attorney general’s authority.  


This marks a historic shift in Israel’s governance, moving toward greater political control over the judiciary—a move critics compare to Hungary and Poland’s democratic erosion.  


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

🏗️ Corporate Complicity in Genocide: The Global Economy Behind Gaza’s Ruin.

📅 July 5, 2025 “We are witnessing not just genocide in Gaza—but a genocide made profitable.” — UN Special Rapporteur, A/HRC/59/23 “This report is written from the heart of darkness . It is penned with a broken hand from a broken land for a broken people . But its words are not broken . They are the words of law and of longing . They are the words of those who are not yet silenced . It is written for Palestinians , first and foremost. It is also addressed to those who remain silent , indifferent or complicit . And it is a call to action for those who are not.” — Introduction, UN Report A/HRC/59/23 In an unprecedented and unflinching report to the UN Human Rights Council, the Special Rapporteur on the Occupied Palestinian Territory has laid bare the truth that much of the world’s corporate, academic, and financial architecture is actively complicit in Israel’s occupation, apartheid, and now, genocide in Gaza. This isn’t just about military aggression . This is about the mac...
3 comments
Read more

Tumbling of American Banks amid weak economic data that sparks recession fears.

 " Citigroup led big bank losses with a near 5 per cent fall. Wells Fargo, Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs fell about 4 per cent each, while JPMorgan Chase and Bank of America declined 2.7 per cent and 3.5 per cent, respectively. Lenders typically feel the squeeze as recessions heighten concerns over credit losses due to higher unemployment, while loan demand – a key factor in profitability – also takes a beating." https://www.businesstimes.com.sg/companies-markets/banking-finance/us-banks-tumble-weak-economic-data-sparks-recession-fears
Post a Comment
Read more

Man does not stand alone by A Cressy Marrison

The American scientist, A Cressy Morrison, Head of the Science Academy   in New York, says in his book "Man Does Not Stand Alone": Birds have the homing instinct. The robin that nested at your door may go south in the autumn, but will come back to his old nest the next spring. In September, flocks of many of our birds fly south,often over a thousand miles of open sea, but they do not lose their way. The homing pigeon, confused by new sounds on a long journey in a closed box, circles for a moment then heads almost unerringly for home. The bee finds its hive while the wind waving the grasses and trees blots out every visible guide to its whereabouts. This homing sense is slightly developed in man, but he supplements his meagre equipment with instruments of navigation.  We need this instinct and our brain provides the answer. The tiny insects must have microscopic eyes, how perfect we do not know, and the hawks, the eagle and the condor must have telescopic vision. Here...
1 comment
Read more

The Ceasefire of Exhaustion: When Empires Collapse from Within

  By Malik Mukhtar — ainnbeen.blogspot.com Two years after Gaza was first set on fire , the war that began with biblical vengeance has stumbled to an exhausted ceasefire . On October 9, 2025 , Israel and Hamas — after endless carnage, famine, and rubble — have signed the first phase of a ceasefire agreement mediated in Sharm el-Sheikh . Trump called it a “ historic peace plan. ” History may call it a truce of attrition — a war that collapsed under the weight of its own hubris. What the Ceasefire Says — and What It Doesn’t Under the agreement, Israeli forces are to pull back to a designated “yellow line” within 24 hours of cabinet ratification. Hamas, in turn, will release all remaining hostages — alive or dead — within 72 hours after the withdrawal. Israel will free about 2,000 Palestinian prisoners, though it made sure to exclude political figures like Marwan Barghouti , whose freedom would remind the world that Palestine still breathes. Humanitarian convoys — food,...
Post a Comment
Read more

WORLD OF EXCESS. Quotes of Corrine Maier

" we live in a world of excess: too many kinds of coffee, too many magazines, too many types of bread, too many digital recordings of Beethoven's Ninth, too many choices of rearview mirrors on the latest Renault. Sometimes you say to yourself: It's too much, it's all too much." ~  " We live in a society of ants, where working and reproducing represent the ultimate objective of the human experience. Work is the opiate of the people; will children be their consolation? A society where life consists of earning a living and raising your kids is a society with no future, since it has no dreams. Having a child is the best possible way to avoid asking what the meaning of life is, as everything revolves around that child, who is a marvellous substitute for the existential quest." "When you are "recruiting" people in temporary positions for the firm ( short term contracts, free lancers) treat them well, remember: they are the ones who actually do a...
Post a Comment
Read more