"States Don’t Have a Right to Exist. People Do." By Peter Beinart. NYTimes .Jan. 27, 2025. Key Points.

Key Points:

1. Consensus in Washington:

Bipartisan agreement exists among U.S. leaders that Israel has a right to exist, as evidenced by statements from figures across the political spectrum.

In 2023, the House affirmed Israel's right to exist by a vote of 412-1.

2. Questioning Israel’s Form of Governance:

The usual focus of U.S. leaders on individual rights contrasts with their support for Israel as a Jewish state, which raises concerns about equal rights for all under its control.

The better question, according to the author, is whether Israel, as a Jewish state, adequately protects the rights of all individuals under its jurisdiction. The conclusion is that it does not.

3. Comparison with Other Nations:

U.S. leaders support democratic reforms in oppressive regimes like Iran and China but exempt Israel from similar scrutiny.

This double standard highlights a focus on the consent of the governed in other states but not in Israel.

4. Rights Denial and Discrimination:

Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank live under Israeli control without citizenship or equal rights.

Even Palestinian citizens of Israel face systemic discrimination in land allocation and representation.

5. American Jewish Leadership and Idolatry of the State:

American Jewish leaders insist on Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state, despite contradictions with democratic principles.

Jewish tradition, which emphasizes skepticism of state power, is at odds with the veneration of Israel as a political entity.

6. Human Rights Abuses:

Israel has been accused of apartheid by its own human rights organization, B’Tselem, and has seen increasing settler violence against Palestinians.

The Gaza conflict illustrates the dangers of denying basic rights, perpetuating cycles of violence and instability.

7. Implications for Jewish Safety:

Denying Palestinians representation and rights leads to violence, endangering both Jews and Palestinians.

The emphasis on maintaining Israel as a Jewish state undermines the principle of equality and fuels ongoing conflict.

Conclusion:

The author argues for a rethinking of Israel’s character, emphasizing the protection of all individuals under its control.

Worship of the state as an absolute value can justify harmful actions and perpetuate inequality.

Source:

NYTimes

Comments

"Hamas Isn't an Existential Threat; the Threats of the Future Are Far Greater" ( Maj. General Rtd.) Yitzhak Brik. Haaretz. Key Points.

Introduction of Yitzhak Brik. Yitzhak Brik is a retired Israeli IDF General. He was born on November 7, 1947 . Brik served in the Armored Corps as a brigade , division , and troops commander , and also commanded the IDF military colleges . He is also a Fellow at the International Institute for Counter-Terrorism (ICT) at Reichman University, Herzliya . During the Yom Kippur War , he served as a reserve company commander and received the Medal of Courage. For about a decade, he served as the Soldier's Complaints Commissioner (Ombudsman) in the Ministry of Defense . More recently, Brik has been a harsh critic of the IDF's preparedness for war and is considered in Israel as the "prophet of wrath" of the 2023 Israel–Hamas war. Yitzhak Brik writes at Haaretz " Hamas Isn't an Existential Threat; the Threats of the Future Are Far Greater" Yitzhak Brik , a retired Israeli Major General, has warned of Israel's potential collapse within a year if the w...

Alleged war crimes in Gaza: Dual Belgian Israeli IDF Veteran, Investigated for Gaza War Crimes.

The dual Belgian-Israeli citizen , suspected of war crimes while fighting for the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) in Gaza , has not been formally arrested as of October 2024 . Instead, Belgian authorities announced the launch of an investigation into the individual's actions . The probe is focused on his alleged participation in civilian executions as part of the IDF's elite " Refaim" (Ghost) unit. The investigation was initiated following a complaint filed by the Association Belgo-Palestinienne (ABP) , and Belgian prosecutors are examining the evidence to determine if charges will be brought against him. 1. The Investigation of an Israeli IDF Veteran Dual Belgian-Israeli Citizen: A Belgian-Israeli man in his 20s , who served as a sniper in the elite IDF "Refaim" (Ghost) unit, is under investigation in Belgium for alleged war crimes in Gaza. War Crimes Allegations: The veteran is accused of executing unarmed civilians during operations ...

"The West Bank as “a Series of Open-Air Prisons” Key Points.

Key Points and Further Details 1. The West Bank as “a Series of Open-Air Prisons” Pastor Munther Isaac describes the current situation in the West Bank as one of its " darkest moments. " Israeli settlements and roadblocks are making the region " uninhabitable ," cutting off built-up areas from each other. Around Bethlehem alone, there are 80 roadblocks , making movement extremely difficult (often taking 6-7 hours to cross ). Economic devastation due to the decline of religious tourism has left churches focused on providing aid to struggling families . 2. The Future of Bethlehem’s Christian Community At least 100 Christian families have left Bethlehem since the start of the war. The Christian population in Bethlehem is already a small community struggling to survive . Forced displacements are increasing, with 45,000 Palestinians already displaced due to Israeli military raids on refugee camps. Fear that the West Bank might suffer the same fate ...

Chris Hedges' essay The Empire Self-Destructs. Key Points.

Breakdown of the main points in Chris Hedges' essay The Empire Self-Destructs , with further details: 1. The Decline of Empire: Hallmarks of Collapse Hedges argues that the U.S. is exhibiting classic symptoms of a declining empire: c orruption, military failures, economic instability, and increasing authoritarianism. Historical comparisons are drawn to the fall of Rome , the Habsburgs , and other collapsed empires. 2. The Cannibalization of Government Billionaires , Christian fundamentalists , and other elites are dismantling the U.S. government for personal and ideological gain. The destruction of state institutions weakens national stability, leading to self-inflicted wounds that hasten collapse. 3. Retreat into Delusion U.S. leadership, particularly under Trump , is detached from reality, replacing facts with conspiracy theories , religious extremism , and empty rhetoric . This results in incoherent policies , such as withdrawing from international agreements and san...

Israel’s Birth and the Roads Not Taken: Revisiting the Alternative Jewish Homelands Debate

Before the establishment of Israel in 1948, several alternative locations were considered for a Jewish homeland, each with its own advantages and challenges. The Uganda Plan (1903) was a British proposal to settle Jews in East Africa , but it was rejected by the Zionist movement for lacking historical and religious significance . The Birobidzhan Project (1930s) , launched by the Soviet Union, aimed to create a Jewish Autonomous Region in the Russian Far East, but harsh conditions and Stalinist purges undermined its success . Nazi Germany’s Madagascar Plan (1930s-1940s) proposed deporting European Jews to the African island , but the idea was unrealistic and tied to anti-Semitic policies . After World War II, some suggested Jewish resettlement in Germany, arguing that Holocaust survivors should be given land there as reparations, but most survivors rejected living on the soil of their oppressors. Lastly, various proposals for Jewish settlement in Aus...

Ainnbeen

Search This Blog