Skip to main content

"Israel Loosened Its Rules to Bomb Hamas Fighters, Killing Many More Civilians" NYTimes. Key Points and Conclusion.

 


Key Points:

1. Change in Rules of Engagement:

On October 7, 2023, Israeli military leadership allowed mid-ranking officers to target lower-ranking Hamas fighters, in addition to high-priority targets like senior commanders and arms depots.

Officers were authorized to risk up to 20 civilian casualties per airstrike, a significant departure from previous limitations.

2. Context of the Change:

The decision followed a major Hamas-led attack that killed approximately 1,200 Israelis, injured many others, and took around 250 hostages.

The attack also raised fears of an invasion by Hezbollah, prompting drastic measures.

3. High Civilian Cost:

The policy resulted in one of the deadliest bombing campaigns of the 21st century, targeting areas where militants were surrounded by civilians, including homes.

4. Weakened Safeguards:

Israel relaxed systems designed to minimize civilian harm.

Previously, many strikes required assurance of zero civilian casualties or were limited to a maximum of five.

5. Investigative Findings:

The New York Times found systemic flaws, including:

Poor methods for selecting targets and assessing civilian risks.

Limited post-strike reviews and accountability for civilian casualties.

Ignored warnings from both Israeli ranks and U.S. military officials.

6. Scale of Bombing Campaign:

The airstrikes targeted thousands of locations, causing widespread destruction in Gaza and substantial civilian casualties.

7. Prime Minister's Statement:

Benjamin Netanyahu declared an intent to turn Hamas strongholds into "rubble," underscoring the scale and intensity of the military campaign.

8. Expanded Military Targets and Civilian Risks:

Israel broadened the scope of military targets in Gaza, including less significant ones, and increased permissible civilian casualties per strike.u

Senior commanders occasionally approved strikes risking over 100 civilian casualties.

9. Intensified Bombing Campaign:

Nearly 30,000 munitions were fired into Gaza in the first seven weeks of the war, exceeding the total used in the next eight months combined.

By November 2023, more than 15,000 Palestinians were killed during the campaign's peak intensity.

10. Flawed Targeting Methods:

Reliance on unproven AI systems and statistical models for target selection led to increased errors.

Some strikes targeted areas hours after last surveillance, heightening risks of hitting civilians.

11. Reduced Precautions:

Israel minimized the use of warning shots ("roof knocks") and often used imprecise or larger bombs, causing widespread destruction.

Precautions in previous conflicts, like thorough surveillance and smaller munitions, were less frequently employed.

12. Evolving Rules of Engagement:

From November 2023, Israel reduced permissible civilian casualties for certain targets and conserved ammunition, but the rules remained more permissive than before the war.

13. Civilian Toll and Global Reaction:

The Gazan health ministry reported over 45,000 deaths, with Israel disputing the figures. The International Court of Justice has been examining accusations of genocide against Israel.

14. Israeli Justifications:

Israel cited the unprecedented scale of Hamas’s attacks, militant use of civilian areas, and Gaza’s tunnel networks as factors necessitating revised rules.

The military maintains that it adheres to international law by employing evacuation warnings and precautionary measures.

15. Case Study – Al-Najjar Family:

A strike targeting Shaldan al-Najjar, a Hamas-allied commander, killed 20 family members, including a 2-month-old infant. In contrast, a similar strike on his home nine years earlier avoided civilian casualties.

16. Hamas's Tactics and Impact on Civilians:

Hamas operates within civilian areas, using residential buildings, medical facilities, and schools for military purposes.

The group hides weapons, fighters, and tunnel entrances in civilian locations, increasing risks to noncombatants.

17. Israeli Military Protocols:

Israel typically employs a multilayered oversight system to ensure compliance with international law during strikes.

Officers assess proportionality and feasibility of precautions to minimize civilian harm but exercise significant discretion due to vague legal standards.

18. Relaxed Standards After Oct. 7, 2023:

Following the Hamas attack, Israeli officers reportedly became less strict in adhering to protocols, leading to widespread destruction and high civilian casualties.

The phrase "harbu darbu" was used to describe a mood of unrestrained attacks within the military.

19. Decreased Use of Precautions:

The use of "roof knocks" to warn civilians became optional and was rarely employed.

Strikes were conducted without warnings, leading to mass casualties, as in the case of Shaldan al-Najjar, where 20 family members and neighbors were killed in a single strike.

20. Increased Risk Tolerance:

On Oct. 7, Israel raised the maximum allowable civilian casualties per strike to 20, which became the standard.

Strikes targeting Hamas leaders, such as Ibrahim Biari, occasionally endangered over 100 civilians.

21. Expanded Targeting Criteria:

Military targets included not just fighters and weapons stockpiles but also infrastructure like tunnel entrances, often located in homes, and financial operatives suspected of handling Hamas funds.

22. Civilian Toll:

Airwars reported 136 strikes in October 2023 that killed at least 15 people each, nearly five times the number during comparable periods elsewhere globally.

Daily casualty caps, such as one allowing up to 500 civilian deaths per day, were introduced but lifted two days later.

23. Widespread Use of Large Munitions:

Israel deployed 1,000- and 2,000-pound bombs, 90% of which were American-made, contributing to significant destruction.

The high usage rate led to a shortage of precision-guided kits, increasing reliance on less precise munitions.

24. Volume of Munitions:

Nearly 50,000 munitions were fired in the first seven weeks of the conflict.

This included approximately 15,000 in October and November 2023 alone.

Monthly munitions usage later dropped to under 2,500 by February–May 2024.

25. Dependence on Older Weapons:

Pilots increasingly relied on unguided, less accurate Vietnam-era bombs due to shortages of precision-guided munitions.

These older bombs sometimes failed to detonate, increasing risks.

26. Targeting Decisions:

One-ton bombs were used to destroy entire buildings, even when smaller munitions could have sufficed.

For example, a U.S.-made JDAM completely destroyed a three-story building, killing multiple members of the Najjar family.

27. "Target Bank" Depletion:

Israel’s "target bank" of pre-vetted locations was exhausted within days.

Intelligence officers had to quickly identify new targets, often relying on AI tools and phone data, which sometimes led to errors and civilian casualties.

28. Errors and Civilian Impact:

Outdated databases and imprecise phone tracking methods contributed to targeting errors.

Civilian casualties often resulted from misidentifications, such as the Malaka family tragedy, where 42 people were killed in a strike based on flawed intelligence.

29. Adjustments in Rules of Engagement:

After initial phases, stricter rules required higher authorization for strikes risking civilian lives.

Despite these measures, many strikes remained deadly, with loose engagement protocols compared to prewar norms.


Conclusion:

While Israel has justified its military operations in Gaza as necessary for targeting Hamas and other militant groups, the methods and scale of these operations have resulted in significant civilian casualties and destruction. Key factors contributing to these outcomes include:

1. High Volume of Attacks: The unprecedented number of munitions fired, particularly in the early weeks of the conflict, led to widespread destruction and civilian deaths.

2. Reliance on Less Accurate Weaponry: Shortages of precision-guided munitions forced the use of outdated and less accurate weapons, increasing risks to civilians

3. Errors in Targeting: Flawed intelligence systems, outdated databases, and rushed decision-making led to numerous civilian casualties due to misidentifications and imprecise assessments.

4. Relaxed Rules of Engagement: Changes in protocols allowed higher thresholds for civilian casualties, further exacerbating harm to non-combatants.

5. Insufficient Accountability: Minimal disciplinary action against military personnel involved in erroneous strikes reflects a lack of rigorous accountability.

Although some measures were later introduced to tighten oversight and reduce civilian risks, they were often too little, too late. The conflict underscores the ethical, legal, and operational challenges of conducting military operations in densely populated civilian areas, raising concerns about proportionality, precision, and adherence to international laws of war.















Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The End of Zionism? Welcome to the Funeral Nobody Wants to Admit Is Overdue

  Of course. Haaretz recently published an opinion piece by Ithamar Handelman -Smith titled “ Some Say It’s the End of Zionism, and I Say That’s All Right .” And what impeccable timing: as Israel carries out a near-two-year campaign of siege, famine, and bombardment in Gaza — slaughtering families, burying aid workers with their ambulances, and literally starving children to death — someone in Israel finally whispers the unspeakable: maybe Zionism, that 20th-century project of “ Jewish salvation ,” has outlived its moral shelf life. Bravo. The house is burning, bodies are scattered in the street, and the philosopher shows up with a garden hose . Zionism: Success Story or Crime Scene? Handelman-Smith argues that Zionism achieved its success : a Jewish state, a safe haven, a fortress against the ghosts of Europe’s crimes . But like every “ success story ” drenched in other people’s blood , it didn’t age well. What began as refuge turned into domination; what was called “ ...

God’s Favorite Real Estate Agents: Smotrich, Ben Gvir, and the Holy Land Realty Circus

  Forget Wall Street. Forget Silicon Valley. The hottest property market today is Occupied Palestine , where homes are not sold with contracts but sanctified with bulldozers, blessings, and bullets. The chief brokers are well known: Bezalel Smotrich , Israel’s Finance Minister, and Itamar Ben Gvir , its National Security Minister. Smotrich doesn’t bother with diplomacy anymore. He boasts that 3,400 new settlement units will “ bury” Palestinian statehood . That’s not zoning — that’s divine grave-digging . Ben Gvir, meanwhile, provides the “ Home Security Package ,” arming settlers like crusader knights on hilltop fortresses and declaring it holy work . All of this would be bad enough if it were just Israeli extremists playing God’s real estate agents . But then came the shocker — the endorsement from the world’s highest court. Enter Judge Julia Sebutinde : a Ugandan jurist, the first African woman to sit on the International Court of Justice (ICJ) , today its Vice-President ,...

Gaza’s Famine: The World Watches Starvation as a Weapon of War

  By Vivian Yee, The New York Times (Aug. 22, 2025) — Reflections and Analysis It is now official: Gaza City and its surrounding areas are in famine. Not “at risk of famine.” Not “approaching famine.” But famine itself — starvation, acute malnutrition, and death. At least half a million people in Gaza Governorate are enduring th e most extreme conditions that the world’s top hunger monitoring group — the U.N.-backed Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (I.P.C.) — measures. With rare exceptions, the other two million residents of Gaza are also suffering severe hunger. The report is unambiguous: famine in Gaza is entirely man-made . It is not drought. It is not nature. It is the direct result of Israel’s blockade of food and aid, relentless bombardment, and the collapse of healthcare, water, and agriculture. “ The time for debate and hesitation has passed. Starvation is present and is rapidly spreading.” — I.P.C. Report By September, famine is expected to engul...

Docu Drama. The voice of Hind Rajab.

The Red Phone Rings, but the World Hits Mute The world just gave a 23-minute standing ovation —yes, twenty-three full minutes of clapping —for The Voice of Hind Rajab at the Venice Film Festival . Applause so long it could’ve filled Hind’s final desperate phone call to the Red Crescent. Bravo, humanity. We couldn’t save her when it mattered, but at least we can applaud her ghost. This is the new morality play: a five-year-old Palestinian child, trapped in a bullet-riddled car , whispering “please come, I’m scared ,” while surrounded by the corpses of her family. The Red Crescent tried . Paramedics drove toward her and were killed too . Israel buried them in silence . And the “ civilized world ”? It buried her in its news cycle . But now—don’t worry— we have a movie . Starring Hind’s voice. Directed by Kaouther Ben Hania. Produced by an ensemble of Hollywood conscience-bearers : Brad Pitt, Joaquin Phoenix, Rooney Mara, Alfonso Cuarón, Jonathan Glazer, Jemima Khan , and others. ...

E-1: The 12 Kilometers That Could Bury a Palestinian State

  Yesterday’s announcement was not just another bureaucratic step —it was a political earthquake . Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich confirmed the green light for 3,401 new housing units in the controversial E-1 area , a strip of land linking Ma’ale Adumim to East Jerusalem . This is no ordinary settlement expansion. The E-1 plan is designed to create an unbroken Israeli-built corridor east of Jerusalem — severing the West Bank’s north (Ramallah) from its south (Bethlehem) and cutting East Jerusalem off from its Palestinian hinterland . In Smotrich’s own words, the move will “ bury the idea of a Palestinian state” by establishing facts on the ground . Why E-1 Matters The E-1 zone —roughly 12 square kilometers —has been a red line in every major peace negotiation since the 1990s . Successive Israeli governments held back full development due to heavy pressure from the United States and the European Union . Until now, it contained little more than an Israeli poli...