Subsidies for Torah Study Amid National Defense Needs: Examining Israel's Haredi Funding Debate.

The recent discourse around Israel's Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) community and their military exemption has intensified, especially in light of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) being stretched thin by ongoing security crises. Prominent voices like Yossi Alpher criticize the Haredi community’s stance, framing their non-participation in the IDF as problematic, particularly given their substantial state funding.

1. Government Funding for Torah Study:

The Israeli government allocates significant funds for Torah study, reflecting the influence of ultra-Orthodox parties within the ruling coalition. The recent budget included an additional 250 million shekels (about $67.5 million) specifically for Haredi men studying in yeshivas instead of working, alongside longstanding subsidies. This budget expansion sparked widespread protests, as many citizens feel the funds should instead support general welfare and military personnel under strain.

2. Child Allowances for Ultra-Orthodox Families:

Beyond educational subsidies, large Haredi families receive additional child allowances. These funds are meant to offset the costs associated with raising children in a society where families often have multiple children. In a recent vote, the government supported child allowance adjustments to cater to ultra-Orthodox demographics, whose community represents nearly 14% of Israel’s Jewish population and has a higher birth rate than the national average.

3. Population Growth and Socioeconomic Impact:

The ultra-Orthodox population in Israel is around 1.3 million, and their numbers are rapidly growing. The higher birth rate combined with relatively low workforce participation, particularly among Haredi men (with only about 51% working), has increased poverty levels in this community to roughly 44%, compared to 22% in the general population. This dynamic places an economic strain on the state and highlights the broader societal debate over the distribution of state resources and the expectations of civic participation through military service.

The debate remains contentious as many in Israel advocate for policy shifts to either reduce financial benefits for those who refuse military service or encourage integration of Haredim into both the IDF and the workforce, potentially using financial incentives to shift current practices.

Comments

Rebranding Genocide: When Killing Learns New Words

There are moments in history when crimes do not end — they simply learn new language. Gaza is living inside such a moment. The bombs have not stopped falling. The children have not stopped dying. The displaced have not stopped freezing in tents pitched atop rubble that was once their homes. What has changed is the vocabulary . And in the modern age, vocabulary is power . If you can rename atrocity, you can anesthetize conscience. First, it was called self-defense — a phrase emptied of meaning by its repetition. Then it became a war , despite the grotesque imbalance: one side armed with one of the most advanced militaries on earth, backed by the world’s most powerful empire ; the other a besieged civilian population without an army, navy, air force, tanks, or safe shelter. Now it is branded a ceasefire — a word invoked not to stop violence, but to conceal it. This is not peace. It is genocide with a quieter soundtrack. The Illusion of Restraint A slowed rate of killing is not m...

The Politicization of Antisemitism: Randy Fine, AIPAC, and the Fight Over Anti-Israel Speech

Randy Fine. Brief introduction of Randy Fine. Randy Fine is a U.S. Representative-Elect for Florida's 6th Congressional District and a former Florida State Senator . Born on April 20, 1974, in Tucson , Arizona , Fine holds degrees from Harvard College and Harvard Business School . He began his political career in 2016 as a member of the Florida House of Representatives and later served in the Florida Senate. Fine is known for his strong pro-Israel stance, earning him the nickname " Hebrew Hammer, " and his socially conservative views . He has been involved in contentious legislation and has faced both support and criticism for his policies and rhetoric. Detailed overview of Randy Fine 's stance and legislative efforts related to criminalizing the distribution of anti-Israel flyers, along with broader context about his political agenda and controversies : --- 1. Randy Fine’s Legislative Efforts Against Anti-Israel Flyers - Florida’s Hate Crime Law (2023): ...

The Berlin Wall of Silence: A Masterclass in "Protecting Democracy" by Choking It

Welcome to Germany, the land of poets, thinkers , and apparently, riot police who are absolutely terrified of Zoom calls. If you’ve been following the news—or trying to, assuming your localized algorithm hasn’t shadow-banned it—you might have noticed that the German state has been busy. Very busy. They are currently engaged in a heroic struggle to protect democracy from its greatest existential threat: people asking for a ceasefire. Here is a celebration of the German police’s most "valiant" efforts to keep the streets safe from the menace of human rights. 1. The "Dangerous" Conference Call In April 2024, Berlin’s finest pulled off the tactical raid of the century. Their target? The Palestine Congress , a gathering of international scholars and activists . The threat level was evidently " Avenger Level," because 900 police officers were deployed to protect the city from... speeches. In a move that screams " stable democracy ," pol...

A Society Pulling Apart: Emigration, Fear, and the Fracturing of Israeli Jewish Resilience

One of the least discussed—and most dangerous—developments in Israel today is not unfolding on its borders, but within its society. The fissures that have opened inside Israeli Jewish society are widening by the day. What began years ago as ideological disagreement has hardened into social estrangement, demographic anxiety , and a growing willingness—especially among secular and liberal Israelis—to imagine a future outside the country. This is not conjecture. It is measurable . The Quiet Indicator of Insecurity: Who Is Thinking of Leaving According to repeated surveys by the Israel Democracy Institute (IDI) , roughly one-quarter of Israelis have seriously considered emigrating , with the numbers rising sharply among secular Jews , young professionals, academics, and high-skilled workers. Among secular Israelis, the share expressing willingness to leave has approached 40% in some surveys —a staggering figure for a country whose national ethos was built on ingathering, permanen...

Historical and Contemporary Perspectives on Anti-Zionism and Anti-Semitism: Navigating the Complexities of Anti-Zionism and Anti-Semitism. JVP.

Key points from the statement by the Academic Advisory Council (AAC) of Jewish Voice for Peace regarding the firing of Maura Finkelstein by Muhlenberg College , along with further explanations: 1. Condemnation of Firing - The AAC condemns the firing of Maura Finkelstein. - The AAC views the firing as unjust and demands her immediate reinstatement. They also call for the removal of key administrative figures at Muhlenberg College, including President Harring , Provost Furge, and Board Chair Lance Bruck . 2. Reason for Termination - Finkelstein was fired for reposting an Instagram message by Palestinian poet Remi Kanazi. - The reposted message was critical of Zionists, which Muhlenberg College cited as the reason for her termination. This action has been reported and corroborated by external sources¹,². 3. Academic Freedom - The AAC argues that the repost falls within the bounds of academic freedom. ...

Ainnbeen

Search This Blog