Marianne Hirsch: The Erosion of Academic Freedom and the Authoritarian Threat to American Universities.

Marianne Hirsch on Free Speech, Authoritarian Tactics, and the Crisis in American Universities

Marianne Hirsch, a renowned scholar of comparative literature and gender studies at Columbia University, is widely respected for her work on cultural memory, trauma, and post-memory (the relationship of second-generation survivors to historical trauma). As a leading academic voice, she has long defended the role of the university as a place of intellectual freedom and ethical responsibility. Now, in light of recent crackdowns on campus activism and freedom of expression, Hirsch raises urgent concerns about the future of academic institutions in the United States.

Marianne Hirsch.

1. Suppressing Speech: A Classic Authoritarian Tactic

Across history, authoritarian regimes have attacked universities and stifled free expression.
Examples include:
- Nazi Germany
- Latin American dictatorships
- Current regimes in Russia, Hungary, and Turkey
The Trump administration weaponized accusations of antisemitism to justify these suppressions, using it as a smokescreen to crack down on dissent.

2. Jewish Voices Must Reject Misuse of Antisemitism

Hirsch stresses: as Jews, we must not allow antisemitism to be manipulated for political gain.
The false narrative conflates legitimate criticism of state policies with antisemitism, undermining genuine efforts to combat real antisemitic threats.
Jewish voices have a responsibility to resist this distortion.

3. Columbia University: A Test Case

Columbia is becoming the battleground for broader attacks on academic freedom.
The detention of student activists like Khalil highlights a dangerous precedent of illegal arrests.
Threats of cutting university funding are part of a larger effort to dismantle higher education’s critical independence.

4. Threat to All: No One is Safe

Hirsch warns that if green card holders can face deportation for activism, everyone is at risk:
- Undocumented students
- International students
- Faculty and staff on visas
- Even permanent residents
These actions foster a climate of fear and surveillance within academic spaces.

5. Erosion of the Academic Sanctuary

Reflecting on her 50 years of teaching, Hirsch recalls a university environment built on:
- Trust
- Deep thinking
- Discovery
- Protection of academic freedom
She expresses deep concern that these values are rapidly eroding.
Once dismantled, rebuilding the integrity and mission of American higher education could take generations.

Conclusion: A Call to Defend Academic Freedom

Marianne Hirsch’s reflections serve as both a warning and a call to action. The attacks on Columbia University are not isolated — they are part of a systemic effort to silence dissent and dismantle the pillars of critical inquiry. In these times, it is essential to defend the university as a sanctuary for free thought and to resist the misuse of antisemitism for political repression.

As Hirsch reminds us, the stakes are high: the future of education, democracy, and intellectual freedom is on the line.

Comments

The Hunger Crisis in Gaza: A Deadly Cycle of Starvation, Suffering, and Refeeding Syndrome

As the siege on Gaza continues to devastate millions, the world watches as a catastrophe unfolds — one of the most heart-wrenching humanitarian crises in recent history . The simple act of eating has become a life-or-death decision for thousands of Gazans, as they struggle to survive on dwindling supplies of food and water. The situation is dire. According to recent reports from The New York Times , nearly 91% of Gaza's population is now facing “food insecurity,” with many enduring “emergency” or “catastrophic” levels of hunger. Bakeries have shut down , and charity kitchens are overcrowded as people wait for a meager meal. The UN has raised alarms that Gaza may already be on the brink of famine , with children showing the visible signs of malnutrition — emaciated bodies, hollow eyes, and weakened immune systems. But the horror doesn’t end with hunger. As Gaza’s population survives on less and less, the collapse of the healthcare system has created a terrifying new danger:...

Turning Lifelines into Leverage: Israel’s Plan to Control Aid in Gaza Sparks Global Outcry

For over two months, Israel has restricted aid access into Gaza —a territory already reeling from massive displacement, bombings, and near-famine conditions. Now, a new plan by Israeli authorities to control aid delivery has sparked outrage from the United Nations and international NGOs. 1. What Is Israel Proposing? Israel wants to create military-controlled “hubs” within Gaza where international aid can be distributed. Under this plan, private contractors would manage the flow of food, medicine, and water—under supervision of Israeli forces. 2. Why Are Aid Groups Refusing? Humanitarian organizations argue that this proposal violates principles of neutrality. They believe it turns life-saving aid into a political tool, essentially using humanitarian support to pressure Hamas and control civilians. “It contravenes fundamental humanitarian principles,” said the United Nations in a joint statement with aid groups. 3. Mass Displacement and Humanitarian Zones As part of its comi...

Tom Segev at 80: Why One of Israel’s Leading Historians Now Calls Zionism a Mistake. Haaretz. Analysis and Summary. Haaretz

Tom Segev. Looking Back, Israeli Historian Tom Segev Thinks Zionism Was a Mistake April 4, 2025 — By Ofer Aderet (Analysis and Summary) Haaretz Israeli historian Tom Segev , long known for his critical lens on the history of Israel and Zionism , has made perhaps his boldest statement yet. At the age of 80, Segev reflects on his personal journey and the historical myths that shaped both his family narrative and the nation’s identity. His revelations , detailed in an in-depth Haaretz article, offer not just a personal reckoning but a broader challenge to Zionism’s moral and historical foundation . Key Themes and Analysis 1. Personal Revelation and Historical Reckoning Segev opens his reflection by confronting a deeply personal myth : the circumstances of his father’s death during the 1948 Arab-Israeli War. For decades, he believed the official narrative that his father, Heinz Schwerin, was killed heroically...

Return to the Killing Fields: When Arab Silence Becomes Complicity

In March 2025 , a flicker of hope broke through Gaza’s smoke-choked skies . Seventeen Palestinian children— each a living testimony to horror —were evacuated from the rubble of their homes and transported to Jordan for medical care. Some arrived with legs blown off at the thigh , tiny bodies bandaged like mummies. One boy, no older than ten , had both arms amputated and his face marked by deep burns —his eyes wide with trauma , silently screaming for comfort . A girl, barely breathing , had shrapnel embedded near her spine and could only speak in whispers —if at all. They came on stretchers , barely conscious , wrapped not in blankets but in sorrow . Their mothers were left behind, many buried under collapsed buildings or lost in the chaos of airstrikes. These children were not just patients— they were war’s rawest wounds, symbols of a people being systematically erased. And then, the unthinkable happened. These same children —these shattered, fragile souls—have now be...

From “Hamas Looked at Me Wrong” to “An Israeli Raped Me”: The Curious Case of Mia Schem’s Shifting Headlines

Ah, Mia Schem . The face of hostage survival , the darling of Israeli media, and, apparently, the victim of just about everyone — depending on which week it is. Let’s rewind . Back in late 2023, Mia was abducted by Hamas during the infamous October 7 Nova music festival attack . Tragic? Absolutely. No one in their right mind would wish such trauma on another human being . She was held for 54 days , wounded, and later released as part of a hostage exchange . S he became a symbol — paraded across global media as proof of Hamas’s inhumanity. In one bizarre interview with Western outlets, she suggested that while in captivity, Hamas fighters “raped her with their eyes.” That’s right. No physical assault reported , no formal accusation — just a poetic kind of violation . A stretch? Many thought so. But hey, nuance was out, and propaganda was in . Fast forward to March 2025. In a surprising twist of narrative, Mia filed a police complaint — not against Hamas , not against some lurking ter...

Ainnbeen

Search This Blog