"Being Jewish After the Destruction of Gaza: A Reckoning". Peter Beinart. Key Points. Theguardian.

Key Points from Peter Beinart’s Interview on Being Jewish After the Destruction of Gaza: A Reckoning.

Peter Beinart.

1. Beinart’s Transformation on Israel and Zionism

Former Defender of Israel: In the early 2000s, Beinart was one of Israel’s most prominent American defenders.

Rejection of Key Zionist Tenets: He now rejects the idea that Israel can be both a Jewish and democratic state.

Support for Palestinian Rights: Advocates for Palestinian refugees’ right to return to historic Palestine.

2. The Book’s Purpose and Audience

Intended for Jewish Readers: Beinart aims to reach Jews who have been uncritical of Israel’s actions.

Addressing Moral Pathology: He believes many Jewish spaces tolerate inhumane views towards Palestinians.

Engaging Younger Jews: Seeks to provide a moral and cultural reckoning for alienated young Jews.

3. Judaism, Morality, and the State of Israel

Judaism as Both Universal and Familial: While Judaism carries a universal ethical message, it also fosters a sense of exclusive communal solidarity.

State Power and Jewish Identity: The combination of Jewish solidarity and Israeli state power has led to rationalizations of violence.

Judaism’s Core Message of Human Worth: Beinart argues that Israel’s actions in Gaza desecrate Judaism’s fundamental belief in human equality.

4. American Jewish Complicity in Israel’s Actions

Unconditional Support for Israel: Many Jewish institutions treat support for Israel as central to Jewish identity.

Forms of Complicity:

Political lobbying (e.g., through AIPAC)

Ritualistic support (e.g., prayers for the IDF in synagogues)

Lack of engagement with Palestinian voices.

5. Beinart’s Personal Journey of Change

Slow Process of Unlearning: Over two decades, Beinart moved away from Zionist narratives.

Impact of Visiting the West Bank: Seeing Palestinian suffering firsthand forced him to confront his biases.

Fear of Social and Career Repercussions: Acknowledges that fear and privilege delayed his shift.

6. Distinguishing Judaism from Zionism

Zionism’s Complex Relationship with Judaism: Initially a nationalist movement that later intertwined with Jewish religious identity.

Zionism and Jewish Symbols: The Israeli flag, menorah, and Star of David have been politicized.

The Double Standard in Jewish Discourse: Jewish leaders conflate Zionism with Judaism while expecting others to separate the two.

7. Engaging with Zionist Students in Progressive Circles

Education Over Exclusion: Encourages dialogue rather than outright rejection.

Challenging Zionist Perspectives: Believes exposing Zionist students to Palestinian voices can be transformative.

Avoiding False Equivalence: While not advocating censorship, he does not equate Zionist identity with white supremacy.

8. The Ceasefire and U.S. Influence

Acknowledges U.S. Leverage: Believes U.S. pressure on Israel led to a temporary ceasefire.

Critique of Israel’s Military Strategy: Argues Israel lacks a political solution for Palestinians, leading to endless cycles of destruction.

9. Hope for Collective Liberation

Beyond Material Optimism: Sees hope as a necessity rather than a rational calculation.

Parallels with South African Apartheid: Believes in a future where Israeli Jews and Palestinians coexist as equals.

A Vision for Reconciliation: Advocates full refugee return and historical justice.

---

Notable Quotes from the Interview

On Jewish Identity and Morality:

> “What Israel has done in Gaza is the most profound desecration of the central idea of the absolute and infinite worth of every human being.”

On American Jewish Complicity:

> “The organized American Jewish community acts as if Palestinians in Gaza have essentially no value.”

On Fear and Personal Change:

> “I was able to shed the preconceptions that so many Jews are raised with about Palestinians—that they have a tendency towards violence.”

On Hope for the Future:

> “Imagine if this story of Palestine and Israel, which is now a story of genocide and apartheid, became a story of collective liberation.”

Beinart’s book serves as both a critique of Jewish support for Israeli policies and a call for moral and political transformation within the Jewish community.

Source:

https://www.theguardian.com/world/ng-interactive/2025/jan/27/israel-gaza-us-jews-peter-beinart?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Comments

Never Attack a Revolution—Unless It’s Gaza

By Malik Mukhtar There is a peculiar confidence that comes with being wrong for decades and still being invited back to explain the world. Yossi Alpher—former Mossad official, veteran intelligence analyst, and institutional voice of Israeli “realism”—offers us precisely that confidence in his January 12, 2026 reflections on Iran. His message, distilled, is simple: things are complicated, revolutions are unpredictable, and humility is required . This is sound advice. It just arrives from the wrong mouth, at the wrong time, over the wrong bodies. Because while Alpher warns us—correctly—not to “attack a revolution, ” Israel has spent the last two years doing something far more obscene : attacking a trapped civilian population with no revolution , no army , no air force, no escape —and calling it self-defense . Intelligence: A Sacred Failure, Repeated Faithfully Alpher recalls, with admirable candor, the catastrophic ignorance of Western and Israeli intelligence during...

Gaza Beyond the Alibi of Hamas: Genocide as Method, Silence as Accomplice.( From Chris Hedges report )

We are the most informed generation in human history—and perhaps the least disturbed by what we know. From the first missiles that struck Gaza’s residential blocks to the slow starvation that followed, everything was visible. Every destroyed home. Every burned hospital. Every child pulled from rubble. And yet, the global emotional temperature barely rose. In an age of total visibility, feeling itself has become scarce. Watching has replaced witnessing. Knowing has replaced responsibility. This moral numbness is not accidental. It is cultivated . And at the center of this cultivation stands a single word, endlessly repeated, ritually invoked, and strategically deployed: Hamas . Hamas has functioned not as an explanation, but as an alibi. The Choice Was Announcedk From Day One From the earliest days of Israel’s assault, the policy was articulated with chilling clarity: Gaza’s population would be given two options— stay and starve, or leave . This was not the language of counte...

Ana Kasparian: The Voice That Won’t Be Silent — A Call for Truth in an Age of Power

Ana Kasparian is one of the most recognized and outspoken voices in contemporary political media. As a co-host of The Young Turks — a trailblazing online news and commentary program — she has spent nearly two decades dissecting U.S. politics, media, power, and foreign policy with unapologetic clarity and fierce conviction. She is not just a commentator — she is a truth-seeker who challenges power at every turn , refusing to soften her words for comfort. Schooled in journalism and political science, Ana’s commentary continues to mobilize millions, especially younger generations who feel unheard in mainstream discourse. A Voice Against the Status Quo Ana’s rhetoric can be bold, controversial, and deeply passionate — because she refuses to accept narratives that obscure the underlying truth about power and influence. On American democracy and foreign policy, she strikes at the heart of what many hesitate to articulate: “ We don’t actually live in a true democracy here in t...

Dr. Randa Abdel Fattah. De-Invited by Association: When Grief Becomes a Pretext and Palestinian Identity a Liability

How Dr. Randa Abdel-Fattah Was Silenced in the Name of “Sensitivity” In a remarkable feat of moral gymnastics, Australia’s literary establishment has once again demonstrated how grief can be weaponised, principles suspended, and Palestinian identity rendered dangerously “inappropriate ” —all in the name of cultural sensitivity. Dr. Randa Abdel-Fattah , a respected author, academic, and public intellectual, was quietly de-invited from Adelaide Writers’ Week following the Bondi Junction massacre. Not because she had any connection—real, implied, or imagined—to the atrocity. Not because she endorsed violence. Not because she violated any law or ethical standard. But because, apparently, the mere presence of a Palestinian Muslim woman who speaks about justice is now considered culturally unsafe during national mourning . One wonders: unsafe for whom? The Logic of the Absurd Festival organisers were careful—almost impressively so—to state that Dr. Abdel-Fattah had nothing to do wi...

Gaza and the Collapse of World Order: When the Guardian of Human Rights Sounds the Alarm

There are moments when the language of diplomacy fails, when caution becomes complicity, and when silence becomes an accomplice to destruction. On January 9, 2026, Agnès Callamard—Secretary General of Amnesty International—crossed that threshold. Her words were unambiguous, unprecedented, and devastating: The United States is destroying world order. Israel has been doing so for the last two years. Germany, through complicity and repression, is helping govern its demise. This was not activist rhetoric. It was a diagnosis from the very institution tasked with guarding the moral and legal architecture of the modern world. The Collapse of the Post-War Moral Architecture The international order that emerged after World War II was built on a promise: never again . Never again genocide. Never again collective punishment. Never again impunity for powerful states. That promise was codified in international law, human rights conventions, and multilateral institutions. But Gaza has...

Ainnbeen

Search This Blog